If novice judges are evaluating entries, who should they be paired with?

Pairing novice judges with a BJCP judge is beneficial because it provides an opportunity for learning and experience. A BJCP judge has been trained and has a deeper understanding of beer styles, evaluation techniques, and the BJCP guidelines, which can guide novice judges in their assessment. This mentorship enhances the educational aspect of the judging process, ensuring that the novice judges receive constructive feedback and practical insights that can improve their judging skills.

In contrast, pairing novice judges with other inexperienced judges could result in a lack of direction and learning opportunities, as both may be unfamiliar with the intricacies of beer evaluation. Allowing novice judges to be paired with a non-BJCP judge might also be problematic, as that person may not possess the structured knowledge necessary to effectively guide the novices. While any available judge could technically be a choice, it would not ensure that the novice judges receive the specialized training and expertise they need to improve their skills.