Is it acceptable to only write 1-2 comments on a scoresheet if you are rushed, as long as the numeric score is filled out?

Providing thorough and constructive feedback on a scoresheet is essential in the Beer Judge Certification Program, and only writing 1-2 comments, even if the numeric score is filled out, does not meet the expectations of judges. The primary goal of a scoresheet is not just to assign a numeric value but to enhance the brewer's understanding of their beer's strengths and weaknesses. Judges are encouraged to provide detailed comments that explain their evaluation of various aspects of the beer, such as aroma, appearance, flavor, mouthfeel, and overall impression.

In situations where a judge is rushed, it remains critical to aim for comprehensive feedback. Limited comments may not give the brewer valuable insights for improvement. Competitions are structured to promote learning and development within the brewing community, which relies on constructive criticism and specific guidance to help brewers refine their craft. Therefore, a minimal response does not align with the standards set by the BJCP and the expectations of participants in competitions.