What does a score in the "Outstanding" range indicate about a beer?

A score in the "Outstanding" range signifies that the beer possesses a unique and extraordinary character. This evaluation takes into account not just the absence of flaws, but the overall impression, creative expression, and how well the beer represents its style while also standing out among its peers. An outstanding beer often showcases exceptional qualities that elevate it above the standard benchmarks, captivating judges and consumers alike with its distinctiveness.

While a beer in this category can indeed be free from flaws, simply lacking imperfections does not automatically confer an "Outstanding" rating. Additionally, a balance of aroma and flavor is commendable but not the sole criterion for an exceptional score; rather, it is the unique character that truly distinguishes an outstanding beer. Popularity among consumers, while relevant in a broader market context, does not directly relate to the technical aspects and quality assessment that the BJCP focuses on when scoring beers. Hence, the essence of an "Outstanding" score fundamentally pertains to the beer's extraordinary character and innovation.