What is an essential quality a judge should maintain while evaluating beers?

Thoroughness in documentation is essential for a judge evaluating beers because it ensures that the evaluation process is both systematic and transparent. This thorough documentation allows judges to record their observations, thoughts, and scoring based on specific criteria, such as aroma, appearance, flavor, mouthfeel, and overall impression. By maintaining detailed records, judges can provide valuable feedback not only for their own reference but also for brewers who may seek insights into their beers.

Furthermore, thorough documentation aids in consistency and fairness in the judging process, enabling judges to revisit their notes and make more informed decisions. This practice contributes to the overall integrity of competitions and helps maintain high standards for judging. Quality feedback and proper disposition of ratings heavily rely on how well judges document their assessments throughout the evaluation.

While other qualities may be beneficial, such as comparative analysis for understanding how a beer stands relative to others or efficient decision-making to keep the process moving, they lack the foundational aspect of thorough and accurate documentation, which is crucial for effective judging and meaningful critique.