What is the correct procedure regarding section scores before writing comments?

The procedure regarding section scores before writing comments emphasizes that scoring should occur prior to providing any feedback. This is essential for ensuring that judges can evaluate each aspect of the beer independently and without bias from their written comments. By scoring first, judges can capture their initial impressions and assessment of specific characteristics, such as aroma, flavor, mouthfeel, and overall impression, based solely on the beer itself.

Scoring before writing comments also allows judges to focus on their assessments without being influenced by their own written critiques. This structured approach helps to maintain objectivity and consistency across evaluations, which is vital for accurate judging according to BJCP guidelines. Once scores are assigned, judges can then reflect on their thoughts and experiences in the written comments, elaborating on their scores and providing constructive feedback to brewers. This sequence ultimately leads to a more thorough and coherent evaluation process.